Replace a seal, save a $1 million dollar project
PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE
Replace a seal, save a $1 million project
By Matt Defosse
Good things come in small packages, with a good example to be found at additive supplier Amfine. Running into serious problems with a dryer used to prepare nucleating agents, the company was able to replace a seal on a vacuum dryer and save a $1 million project.
Seals and other replacement parts often do not get much thought from the plastics community until it's rime to refurbish or conduct scheduled maintenance on a piece of equipment. There are times, though, when a bad seal can bring an entire project to a halt, as additives and PVC stabilizer supplier Amfine Chemical Corp. (Hopkinsville, KY) discovered when it was ramping up a line to produce a nucleating agent that also serves as a clarifying agent for semicrystalline polymers.
Amfine is a joint venture of Adeka Corp. and Mitsubishi Corp. of Japan, with it primarily serving plastics processors in the Americas. For this nucleating agent, making the product included drying under vacuum so that no oxygen enters the process during drying. Dryer batches run 24/7 until completed. The product must pass two critical quality tests: one measures the level of solvent remaining in the product and the other measures the level of dissolved color.
The drying process removes a solvent used in upstream production; the higher the temperature in the dryer, the more solvent can be removed. Temperature must be finely controlled to achieve a low dissolved color value {high clarity), as too high or low a temperature can leave the product cloudy and therefore undesirable for customers' products. Usual running temperature in the dryer can exceed 240°F. The values for solvent and color content are documented on each batch of product produced.
Murphy's Law comes to town
When Amfine's process engineers originally specified the capabilities of the dryer they needed to its manufacturer, they assumed that if it could hold I00 Torr (13,330 Pa) of vacuum, the process would be successful. The dryer was delivered with some blow/cut seals installed, which were designed to hold the prescribed 100 Torr. These seals were composed of a series of Teflon lip seals, with nitrogen blown into chambers between the layers. They consumed a large amount of nitrogen purge gas.
As they ran the first batches of product in the new dryer and tested the results for solvent content and dissolved color numbers, Amfine's experts realized that they needed to achieve a much deeper vacuum in order to reach the target values for solvent and color: A value of 50 Torr or less was needed in order to dry at a low-enough temperature to hit their targets. After making several changes to the configuration of the original seals, operators reported getting closer to the 50-Torr level in the dryer, but the product still did not meet QC standards.
The level of vacuum achieved with the factory-installed seals was inconsistent from batch to batch, so cycle times for the dryer ranged widely.
Nitrogen purge gas entering the dryer from the factory-supplied seals was making it impossible to achieve the 50-Torr level. The addition of nitrogen to the process had a secondary effect, to decrease the bulk density of the product, making it fluffier. The result of this was that fine particles began to clog the outlet filters, increasing the pressure differential between the inside and outside of the dryer, a potentially dangerous condition.
Mastering Murphy
After some searching, Amfine's facilities manager, Scott McNair, contacted shaft seal manufacturer MECO's regional distributor, Jerry Chevalier of Mid South Mechanical Sealing in Tennessee. After visiting Amfine, where he helped the maintenance team to measure the dryer shaft and the space around it for a custom seal, MECO (Georgetown, ME) quoted a split, elastomer-free ExPac (EP) model seal with a mechanical drive mechanism. These seals can accommodate axial shaft growth in applications with wide temperature and pressure variances such as this one had, and can hold vacuum effectively. The elastomeric drive version of the ExPac was ruled out due to the high temperature and chemical compatibility considerations in the application. The split design was critical because the retrofit of the dryer would take much less time if the bearing and drive could be left intact. The seal was delivered and installed in late April 2008. Chevalier helped with installation of the seal and to oversee the startup of the machine with the new seal in place. A seal sleeve slightly wider than the shaft diameter was removed to maximize available space for the new seal. The EP seal required a nitrogen purge, but with a significantly reduced flow rate compared to the first seal (from several hundred to near zero cfm).
Happy and profitable ending
When the seal was installed, plant operators were hoping that the dryer could pull a vacuum deeper than 50 Torr. In fact, it is able to consistently approach zero Torr with the new seal. Dryer cycle times became predictable, and consistent achievement of deep vacuum resulted in more consistent product quality and higher profitability for Amfine. The ExPac seal is designed for its seal face pressure to be adjusted occasionally as rotating faces wear over time. In the first 2 1/2 years of operation, the seals have not needed to be adjusted yet. McNair goes so far as to say that the seals "literally saved a $1 million project."